The question I hear most, from Hingham to Kingston, is: “Do natural tick sprays work as well as what you use?” It’s a fair question, so here’s the short answer based on the research.

The Short Answer

Most natural sprays don’t hold up. Professional-grade products work better and last longer.

What the Research Found

A four-year, CDC-supported field study (Jordan et al., 2020) compared a professional product, bifenthrin, with 10 popular “natural” tick sprays:

  • Bifenthrin was still killing ticks four weeks after spraying, every year of the study.
  • Only 4 of the 10 natural products killed a meaningful number of ticks right away.
  • Only 1 of the 10 was still working two weeks later.

A broader CDC review (Eisen and Eisen, 2016) found that professional treatments like ours typically gave 85% to 95%+ control of young deer ticks for up to seven weeks.

Why “Natural” Doesn’t Always Mean “Works”

Many natural sprays are “minimum-risk” products that the EPA doesn’t review for effectiveness. “Natural” tells you what’s in the bottle, not whether it kills ticks.

To be fair, a couple of plant-based ingredients have tested well, like nootkatone (from grapefruit and cedar, registered by the EPA in 2020). So the real question isn’t natural vs. synthetic. It’s whether there’s solid field data behind the product.

How We Treat Your Yard

At Mosquito-Cop, we use bifenthrin, the treatment CDC researchers consider the most consistently effective for deer ticks. We apply it carefully where ticks actually live:

  • Yard edges, stone walls and brush lines
  • Shady beds and leaf litter
  • Lawn borders next to woods

We follow the label every time, skip flowering plants to protect pollinators, keep clear of ponds and marsh edges, and ask you to keep kids and pets off treated areas until they’re dry.

Keep Up the Tick Checks

No spray makes a yard 100% tick-free. Keep doing daily tick checks on your family and your dog, and rake up leaves. A yard treatment is your first layer of protection, not the whole plan.

One Tip Before You Hire Anyone

Ask: “Are you licensed?” Our team is licensed with the state, and you can check any company for free with the Massachusetts pesticide license lookup.

Get Reliable Protection This Season

Mosquito-Cop is local and owner-operated, serving Cohasset, Duxbury, Hanover, Hingham, Kingston, Marshfield, Norwell, Pembroke, Plymouth and Scituate.

Call or text (781) 490-3752, or Request a Quote at Mosquito-Cop.com.


Sources